Wednesday 3 December 2008

Michelin guide Hong Kong Macau 2009

"Michelin Guide Hong Kong Macau 2009" is the first bilingual Michelin guide. Hong Kong has become one of the first Michelin cities in China. It includes 202 establishments in Hong Kong, with 22 of them receiving one or more Michelin stars.

There were 12 Michelin inspectors (2 of them were Chinese) who examined a pre-selected 1,200 of the 15,000 restaurants. 200 restaurants were chosen to appear in the guide. Among the 200 restaurants, 33 of them belongs to hotels' restaurant.

3 STARS *** (the top Michelin grade for "exceptional cuisine worth a special journey.")
  • Lung King Heen 龍景軒 (Four Seasons Hotel)
2 STARS ** (excellent cooking worth a detour)
1 STAR * (a very good restaurant in its category)
Special Recommendation (no star but recommended)

Many local gastronomes & gourmets doubt the Michelin judges ratings were fair. For example Yung Kee 鏞記 serves the best roasted goose in the world (Hong Kong has the best roasted goose in the world, while Yung Kee 鏞記 offers the best roasted goose in town.), should deserve at least 2 stars instead of 1 star.

What did the local gourmets say about "Michelin guide Hong Kong Macau 2009"?

李純恩: I will not follow this guide to eat. Western people do not understand the pith of Chinese cooking and food culture. They only appreciate restaurants in luxury hotels. Hongkongers no need to boarder.

劉健威: Michelin judges' standards are typical tourists' standards, which are very different from the locals. With a limited time tasting pre-selected restaurants from luxury locations. You are very safe at 5-star hotels, you don't normally find bad food there, however, also hard to get surprise. They should spend more time investigating and understanding Chinese food culture.

Chow Chung: Chinese have their own standard of good food. As you don't trust Chinese people's rating s and comments on Western food. This guide used a Western perspective to rate the restaurants, I doubt any local will follow their culinary map.

No comments: